ROB KOONS
  • Home
  • Published articles
  • Work in Progress
  • Lectures
  • Contact and Links
  • Old Blog (2021-22)

The Rigorous Thomist

A Blog by Rob Koons

Is God the Cause of Human Sin?

7/20/2021

0 Comments

 
Summa Theologiae, I, Q49, a1 and a2; I-II, Q9, a6; I-II, Q75, a3; I-II Q79, a1
 
In Part I, Q49, a1, Thomas explains that evil has no per se efficient cause, but it does always have a per accidens efficient cause. Every evil act or situation is good insofar as it exists, and something must cause per se that element of goodness. However, there need be no per se cause of the deficiency that is evil in the thing. When something good causes something bad, there is always some pre-existing deficiency of some kind, either in the agent or the patient, or both.
 
Since there is no defect in God, when God causes something that is evil, there must be some pre-existing defect in the patient. As Thomas puts it in reply 2, “And, likewise, whatever there is of being and action in a bad action, is reduced to God as the cause; whereas whatever defect is in it is not caused by God, but by the deficient secondary cause.”
 
When Thomas explains, in I-II Q9, a6, how God moves the human will, he points to two ways. First, God causes our nature, which includes the free will and its natural inclinations. And, second, God is absolute goodness—so every apparently good thing that moves the will does so because of its apparent participation in God’s goodness. In neither of these ways is God responsible for our sin.
 
In I-II Q75, a3, Thomas insists that nothing external to the will can necessitate sin. God is the cause of the movement of the will that is sin, but God (in His essence) does not necessitate that the will choose badly.
 
In I-II Q79, a1, “Whether God is a cause of sin,” Thomas summarizes his conclusions:
 
“Now God cannot be directly the cause of sin, either in Himself or in another, since every sin is a departure from the order which is to God as the end: whereas God inclines and turns all things to Himself as to their last end, as Dionysius states (Div. Nom. i): so that it is impossible that He should be either to Himself or to another the cause of departing from the order which is to Himself. Therefore, He cannot be directly the cause of sin.”
0 Comments

    Author

    Rob Koons, a professor of philosophy, trained in the analytic tradition at Oxford and UCLA. Specializing in the further development of the Aristotle-Aquinas tradition in metaphysics and the philosophy of nature.

    Archives

    August 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021

    Categories

    All
    Acts Of Existence
    Actualism
    Actuality
    Agency
    Being
    Causal Finitism
    Causation
    Change
    Classical Theism
    Contingency
    Design
    Divine Freedom
    Divine Simplicity
    Efficient Causation
    Essence
    Eternity
    Ethics
    Evil
    Existence
    Fifth Way
    First Cause
    First Mover
    First Way
    Five Ways
    Fourth Way
    Free Will
    God's Existence
    Goodness
    Grace
    Grim Reaper
    Haecceity
    Immateriality
    Infinite Regress
    Infinity
    Instrumental Causation
    Intelligence
    Joe Schmid
    Justice
    Kalam Argument
    Knowledge
    Love
    Matter
    Maximum Being
    Metaethics
    Modal Collapse
    Modality
    Motion
    Necessary Being
    Parts/Wholes
    Passions
    Passive Potentiality
    Patchwork Principle
    Perfection
    Persistence
    Platonism
    Potentiality
    Powers
    Predestination
    Prime Matter
    Providence
    Pure Actuality
    Real Distinction
    Relativity
    Scotism
    Second Way
    Sin
    Substantial Change
    Teleology
    Third Way
    Time
    Unity Of God
    Virtue
    Will Of God

    RSS Feed

Site powered by Weebly. Managed by Bluehost
  • Home
  • Published articles
  • Work in Progress
  • Lectures
  • Contact and Links
  • Old Blog (2021-22)